Executives
have always been privileged users. As security practitioners we tend to
think of privileged users as those administrators with outsized access
to sensitive information, necessitated by their role in keeping IT
services running, presenting risk that requires dedicated mitigation
efforts. But when we consider the access rights that executives have to
sensitive information, and the authority they wield, we find hidden risk
that may not be fully appreciated.
This is evident in the recent revelations of a private email server
used by Hillary Clinton during her tenure as Secretary of State. In the
ultimate example of shadow IT, she and her staffers took it upon
themselves to stand up an IT service, hosted in her own home, which
escaped the purview of the Department of State’s IT team.
The rising risk of executive policy evasion
We
can leave the discussion of motivation and the legality of Secretary
Clinton’s actions to the political class. But it does provide a public
example of how tempting it is for executives to operate outside of
policy.
Not
every executive wants to dedicate space in their bathroom to an email
server. But there are companies without a BYOD policy where executives
insist on using personal tablets. Yahoo’s CEO famously refused to put a passcode
on her personal phone. Some execs retain access to sensitive
information following retirement. They insist on downloading software
from any Internet site they want to. With authority and resources,
convenience is easily prioritized over policy.
The implications of executive policy circumvention
In
the case of Secretary Clinton, while there are some political costs,
the security implications have yet to be determined. But we know that
Top Secret information was transmitted over what is likely a network
that wasn’t equipped to safeguard it. The US Government applies the Top
Secret classification to information that, if disclosed, “could be
expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security.”
If her personal server was a target of foreign state actors, the implications are frightening.
Beyond
governments, those companies with the most to lose from data breaches
as a result of executive policy circumvention are those with significant
intellectual property. Drilling technology in the oil and gas industry,
pharmaceutical patents in development, or blockbuster movies being
filmed are a few examples.
Addressing the risks
Although
executives are privileged users, they are likely to chafe at the kind
of restrictions typically placed on administrators. Privileged identity
management techniques include password vaulting, controls over commands a
user can execute, and monitoring and recording activity. While
executives are unlikely to accept a need to check out credentials from a
password vault, more passive security techniques, specifically user
activity monitoring, may be an acceptable alternative.
If
they understand what is at stake, unobtrusive monitoring that doesn’t
restrict their work can identify abnormal use of their access that could
indicate an abuse of privileges by an outsider.
To
mitigate the risk of attackers obtaining executive credentials,
multi-factor authentication (MFA) should also be considered. We know
that if it is inconvenient, though, executives will circumvent or avoid
the use of security controls. So selection of easy-to-use authentication
methods, such as effective thumbprint readers or a YubiKey, is
critical.
In
democracies, politicians are ultimately accountable to voters, and it
would seem that voter visibility of the Clinton email situation is
currently at an all-time high. Ultimately, executives are accountable to
boards. If executives are circumventing security policies, perhaps that
activity should have board-level visibility. It’s unreasonable to
expect personnel who report to executives to provide that visibility, so
it will be up to external auditors to raise awareness as necessary.

ConversionConversion EmoticonEmoticon