Malware
that leverages a computer’s graphics processing unit (GPU) made
headlines earlier this year when researchers developed several
experimental threats designed to use the GPU for enhanced stealthiness.
However, experts from Intel Security believe such malware still leaves
traces that can be picked up by endpoint protection solutions.
Malware
that uses the GPU has been around for several years; the most common of
these threats are Trojans that harness the power of the GPU for Bitcoin
mining.
In May, researchers released source code
for three pieces of malware designed to leverage the GPU: a keylogger
(Demon), a Linux user-mode rootkit (Jellyfish), and a Windows remote
access tool (WIN_JELLY). These programs demonstrated that GPU-based
malware can maintain persistence through warm reboots, it can access CPU
host memory via Direct Memory Access (DMA), and it can delete the CPU
host files after installation. Experts have also pointed out that there
aren’t many GPU analysis tools available.
In
its McAfee Labs Threats Report for August 2015, Intel Security analyzed
each of these points in an effort to provide additional context on the
threat posed by GPU malware and available defenses.
Intel
Security has pointed out that applications designed to access the GPU
need a parent process that runs on the CPU. The activities carried out
by this parent process in the case of regular malware, such as reading
and writing memory, can be detected by security products. By accessing
the CPU host memory from the GPU, protections can be bypassed and
malicious activity can remain hidden.
However,
when delivering the payload, physical memory must be mapped to the GPU,
which requires Ring 0 access on the operating system. This adds to the
malware’s footprint on the host and is covered by existing kernel
protections, Intel Security said.
While
GPU malware can delete the kernel driver and the parent usermode
process following installation in an effort to avoid detection, this
leaves the code running on the GPU orphaned. On Windows systems, this
leads to the initiation of a Timeout Detection and Recovery (TDR)
process that resets the graphics card, researchers noted. Modifying TDR
settings to prevent this from happening would be suspicious since
Microsoft recommends such changes only for testing and debugging
purposes.
The
researchers who developed Jellyfish noted that the malware can maintain
persistence across warm reboots. However, in the case of the
proof-of-concept rootkit, while the executable code remains stored in
the GPU after reboot, it cannot be executed without a host process that
is also launched at system startup.
Intel
Security agrees that there aren’t many GPU forensics and malware
analysis tools. However, the company has pointed out that while such
tools would be useful for understanding the inner workings of GPU-based
malware, endpoint security products should still be able to detect
threats based on other indicators of attack.
“GPU
threats are a real concern. But this type of attack has not reached
perfect storm status. On one hand reverse engineering and forensic
analysis of such threats is much more complex and challenging than their
pure CPU counterparts, and this may result in an infection going
unnoticed for a longer period. By moving part of malicious code off of
the CPU and host memory, the detection surface is reduced—making it more
difficult for host-based defenses to detect attacks,” Intel Security
noted in its report. “On the other hand, the detection surface has not
been completely eliminated. At a minimum, trace elements of malicious
activity remain, allowing endpoint security products to detect and
remediate the threat.”
“Undoubtedly
there will be advancements made in this area by both attackers and
defenders. If nothing else, the recent attention to this area has
resulted in the security community’s reevaluating its current posture
and exploring ways to improve upon it,” wrote the authors of the report.
The
complete McAfee Labs Threats Report for August 2015, which also details
data ex-filtration and a five-year retrospective of the collaboration
between Intel and McAfee, is available for download in PDF format.
ConversionConversion EmoticonEmoticon